Once a judge or a jury renders a verdict in an Indiana personal injury case, that verdict is final unless one of the parties involved decides to file an appeal to a higher court. Importantly, Indiana appellate courts will not revisit factual determinations of a judge or jury. This means that issues of credibility are not appealable. However, legal claims of error, such as evidentiary issues, can be appealed if the issue is properly raised and preserved below.
Indiana appellate courts receive thousands of appeals each year, and they employ a strict set of procedural rules to ensure that only the most diligent parties with meritorious claims of error are heard. One of the most commonly encountered rules of appellate procedure is the requirement that a claim of error must be raised at trial in order for an appellate court to consider the alleged error on appeal.
Due to this rule, a party’s failure to raise and preserve an issue at trial will almost certainly prevent that party from bringing the issue to the attention of an appellate court. A recent personal injury case involving a serious slip-and-fall accident illustrates how this rule affected one plaintiff’s ability to recover compensation for his injuries.